Who is most to blame? (Poll)

SeahawkSteve80 · May 23, 2026

As of today, May 23, 2026, the Mariners set at 25-28. They had enormously high expectations entering the season, but up to this point, they haven’t quite lived up to the hype.

Now, there’s a long way to go still in the season. Who knows what the future holds, but up to this point, my question is: who is most to blame for the slow start?

Is there a particular player, manager, position coach, front office person, etc who you believe is the crux of the issue? Share your thoughts below.

SeahawkSteve80 · May 23, 2026

I voted for Dan Wilson. He just seems incompetent when it comes to setting the lineup, players appear lost and confused, and his routinely poor bullpen decision making continues to blow my mind. I want him gone yesterday.

For instance, Refsnyder batting in the 4 spot, considering how poorly he’s hitting the ball. Why? Just….why? Does he want to lose?

hawkfan68 · May 23, 2026

I voted for the guy who hired Dan Wilson. He's been the source of the issues since he's been here.

Chapow · May 23, 2026

To me, it doesn't make much sense to blame the employee that's following orders. It makes much more sense to blame the boss that's issuing the orders.

Personally, I think Dan is essentially just Dipotos puppet, and just does what he's told to do.

hawkfan68 · May 23, 2026

Chapow said:
To me, it doesn't make much sense to blame the employee that's following orders. It makes much more sense to blame the boss that's issuing the orders.

Personally, I think Dan is essentially just Dipotos puppet, and just does what he's told to do.

What managerial experience did Dan Wilson bring before being hired by M's? That should give a clue as to what type of manager he would be and why he was hired in the first place.....a "yes" man at his finest.

SeahawkSteve80 · May 23, 2026

My bad for not including “other” on this pole. Use my name for “other” lol

Azvacar · May 23, 2026

SeahawkSteve80 said:
My bad for not including “other” on this pole. Use my name for “other” lol

If you hadn't put Wilson on there you were first on my list buddy! haha

SoulfishHawk · May 24, 2026

SeahawkSteve80 said:
I voted for Dan Wilson. He just seems incompetent when it comes to setting the lineup, players appear lost and confused, and his routinely poor bullpen decision making continues to blow my mind. I want him gone yesterday.

For instance, Refsnyder batting in the 4 spot, considering how poorly he’s hitting the ball. Why? Just….why? Does he want to lose?

He doesn't seem incompetent....he has PROVEN that he is exactly that.

SoulfishHawk · May 24, 2026

hawkfan68 said:
What managerial experience did Dan Wilson bring before being hired by M's? That should give a clue as to what type of manager he would be and why he was hired in the first place.....a "yes" man at his finest.

Seattle Mariners: we always have 1995

SeahawkSteve80 · May 24, 2026

No votes for Humpy?

SoulfishHawk · May 24, 2026

They always do humpy dirty. So to speak....

IndyHawk · May 24, 2026

I blamed Steve because it's a team game, they win together and lose together.

Shane Falco · May 24, 2026

Gotta be Dipoto. He's been here for over 10 years now. Outside of getting close last season hasn't won us squat.

But it's really hard for me to complain this season because I was down with what he did in the off season. Resigning Naylor and trading for Donovan were some pretty good/logical moves imo that I thought might get us over the hump.

This team is cursed.

SuperSonic67 · May 24, 2026

I agree with above…thought that the moves going into this season were certainly good enough to get to 88-90 wins, which in this division is usually enough. In that regard I blame Dan so far this season for not making even average in game decisions, and in turn not motivating his players. If it’s Jerry pulling the strings then shame on Dan for taking the job, this will be his only managerial job in the MLB if he’s that big a a puppet/pushover. It’s his resume…

The sustained long term disappointment season after season is all on Jerry and ownership though.

Sperrydogg · May 26, 2026

Shane Falco said:
Gotta be Dipoto. He's been here for over 10 years now. Outside of getting close last season hasn't won us squat.

But it's really hard for me to complain this season because I was down with what he did in the off season. Resigning Naylor and trading for Donovan were some pretty good/logical moves imo that I thought might get us over the hump.

This team is cursed.

Last year was half luck too. At what point during the season last year were we saying this a World Series team…

I blame Jerry.. he built this roster that is supposed to be greater than the sum of its parts. But all these pieces that only are supposed to have one job are not doing there job.

Last year it was rowdy telez this year it’s refersmokeer and Joe…

Jerry is closing his eyes and throwing darts at balloons

SoulfishHawk · May 26, 2026

Good points. They do love their leftovers.

onanygivensunday · May 26, 2026

I blame the Mariner Moose... for no particular reason... I just do.

cymatica · May 26, 2026

This team is cursed. If they broke the bank for the best combination of management and players their plane would go down after takeoff

SoulfishHawk · May 26, 2026

At this point, they'll never make a WS in my lifetime. Pathetic

Sperrydogg · May 26, 2026

Tony Larusa?

Who is most to blame? (Poll)

Who is most to blame for the slow start?

Dan Wilson

Jerry Dipoto

John Stanton

Edgar Martinez

Cal Raleigh

Rob Refsnyder

Andres Munoz

SeahawkSteve80

Humpy

Brendan Donovan

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Similar threads