Sperrydogg
Well-known member
- Joined
- Oct 1, 2023
- Messages
- 8,106
- Reaction score
- 6,332
Do the mariners have almost a complete lineup of major league hitters? It’s been so long I forgot what it really looks like to see a team that can all play…
Regardless of struggled, with the new roster construction he should be at the bottom. If you put him lead off you’re basically forced to hit Naylor or Geno 6th. Nothing against JP, but even when he’s hitting he doesn’t deserve to be at the top of the lineup.
If JP is the liability in the lineup, that shows just how good we are.
I like JP at leadoff, I’m not gonna pretend he wasn’t in a slip and Danny knocked him right outa that slump with a little break from the spot and now he’s relaxing again. I think we have at least three good leadoff guys including Julio and I’d like to see a little more changing it up and flexibilityI'm gonna have to beg to differ that he doesn't deserve to be at the top of the lineup when he's hitting.
There were 93 games before the all star break. Well over half a season. In those 93 games, JP hit for a .291 average with a .391 OBP and a .782 OPS. That OBP was well inside the top 10 in all of baseball. If I'm not mistaken, the #1 priority for a leadoff hitter is setting the table for the rest of the lineup (aka get on base). He was doing that at an elite level while also hitting for a very good average and a well above league average OPS.
Even after an extreme slump since the break, he's still hitting for a very, very good average with RISP (.320). Miles better than Julio (.200), Cal, (.230), or Arozarena (.200). I get that people are pissed or whatever that he's been playing so poorly lately, but the non clutch accusation is simply wildly untrue. Especially compared to the guys that are the heart of our order.
Honestly, I think JP is one of those guys that a lot of M's fans just don't like very much for whatever reason. Even when he's playing really well, it seems like it largely goes unnoticed and/or unappreciated. The moment he hits a rough patch, people can't wait to pounce and just go after the guy relentlessly. I just don't get it.
Anyway, right as I'm about to click on the post button, JP leads off the bottom of the 6th with a double. Won't matter, fans will start tearing him apart again at the next available opportunity.![]()
I disagree because could not get out of his own head at the plateLeading off has a lot of pressure attached to it. We basically ruined Kelenic by having him lead off for what? 40 games or something and just watched him flounder. No way to treat a rookie.
JP is a vet, TBS, but it is still a big ask to lead off every day, and when you're struggling like he has been, decreasing the pressure by moving him to the back of the order for a while can help. Will he ever be moved back up? Time will tell, but when he was on for several months there he was a dynamic leadoff hitter, getting on base a lot and creating pressure on the opposing pitcher for the big bats behind him.