Weak leg or not, he was fairly accurate, and that's what it's all about.
I think if you can hit from less than 53 on a regular basis, you're good. I mean, sure, there are a handful of times that a really long field goal has changed the course of the game, but does the team that wins it because of a 62-yarder after giving up 4 deep balls and throwing 3 picks really deserve to win?
Nope, I'll take a kicker that can hit every time, from a max of 53-54, and play great offense and defense to win games.