RichNhansom":3f3bjruc said:
You won 1 game at 10 am last year and that was against the Jets. You lost to the Vikes and Rams at 10 am and in fact beat the Packers and Patriots later in the afternoon. Not sure how you can agree with Houston other than to try and make it look like we are complaining about the start times. You guys were heavily pampered by the schedule makers and still barely won the division.
As for the draft picks, I could care less about any of them at this moment. Right now every single one of them is a bust until they prove otherwise. That goes for you even more than us because you are going to be forced to play multiple rookies even if they don't pan out because you don't have any other options and that in itself is sketchy because everyone knows Harbaugh doesn't like to play rookies.
As for Quinn, he has been the D-line coach on some horrific teams, including the Niners in 03-04. Primarily this is Pete's defense and Pete likes Quinn. He was originally slotted to be our D-coord before Gus Bradely blew Pete away and stole the position. He is still a question mark in some regards but we aren't relying on him as much as we are on Pete.
Not sure what so many question marks are. We brought in proven talent to shore up every single question we had to end last season. Sure they still need to prove it but I will take a player who has played at a high level in the NFL vs a rookie who has yet to see a snap and day of the week and twice on Sunday.
I think the question marks are much more glaring on the Niners side. Both offensively and defensively. You have two (count em two) players returning that have caught passes from Kaep in Davis and Crabtree. Boldin could be a good pick up but there will be a learning curve between him and Kaep to become comfortable. Frank gore turns 30 in about a week and you don't have a proven backup TE/Hback.
Defensively you are relying on a rookie to replace an all-pro, a rookie at NT and Justin Smith turns 34 in September. Is Aldon the same player without Justin?
Feel free to tell me about the question marks all over the Seahawks defense because I don't really see any at all other than what I have already pointed out.
Anytime a pro player like Avril or Bennet come to your team from another team, there's question marks. Avril, looks like he'll be a pass rusher in your defensive system but when the 49ers played Detroit and they handled him pretty well. Bennet looks to be a DT in your 4-3 defense but when the 49ers played Tampa Bay they handled him too. Red Bryant looks like a pretty good player, but he's often injured. Jesse Williams looks like a good draft pick, but again we'll see.
So you believe a rookie will not be a bigger question mark at NT for you than proven NFL caliber players will be for us? Wasn't Justin Smith injured last year? Seems like we could get by much better without Red than you can without Smith. I could just as easily say anytime Justin Smith gets injured Aldon becomes useless. May or may not be true but it is definitely a bigger question than will Avril or Bennet work out. Again, until draft picks become NFL players, I don't count them for us or you. They are the biggest question mark of either team.
Avril, Bennet, and Jesse remind me of the atrocious D line that the 49ers had back in '04. The only good player they had on that line was Bryant Young. The rest of that line couldn't rush the passer or stop the run. Engleburger and Peterson, were often road graded every weekend. Avril and Bennet sorta remind me of those to guys the 49ers had back then. Jesse reminds me a bit of Anthony Adams.
I see your opinion but what did Clemmons remind you of when he played for Philly? Avril has ten times the resume of what Clemons had coming in and we got Philly to throw Clemons with a 4th in on a trade for Daryl Tapp. The only thing I question about our Dline right now is whether Clemons will be back to 100%. The rest of it looks pretty damn good to me.
Both teams have done their best to upgrade their pass rush and I think done a good job. While the 49ers have an elite pass rusher, you guys are still looking for one. You may have sacrificed too much run defense for the pass rush. While the 49er defensive coaching staff is intact from last year, your coaching staff is undergoing some reconstruction. Again, I think you have good potential to be one of the better defenses in the NFL this year, but with all those question marks, you can easily drop back to mediocrity. The 49ers can too, of course. It goes both ways.
Or we may have in fact bolstered our run defense with additions of Winfield and Bennett. Your elite pass rusher didn't look so elite once Justin was hurt in fact he dissapeared. That is as big a question as any. Quinn was a dline coach here for Pete two years ago and was slotted to be the DC before Bradley (as I explained earlier) I don't think it really qualifies as a reconstruction espeacially when it is Pete's defense. Pete already knows the guy, what he brings and how he coaches. I'm not worried about that aquisition. In fact I am excited about it because I don't believe Bradely was all that great of a D-coach. Pete brought Quinn with him when he arrived. Bradley just blew him away in his interview.