When the ncaa rules and state law are different, what’s a school to do?

[WmHBonney]

I made the thread to discuss specifically how ncaa might handle the increasing number of states banning Transwomen in women’s sports.

If the ncaa allows bio males To compete as a national policy, they At minimum have to exclude schools with contrary state laws from hosting competitions in Which a bio male is competing.

Meanwhile, bio female’s opportunities will necessarily Diminish the More bio males join it. (Serena Soule, a former hs track star now suing, has listed 85 girls track records that were affected by two bio males who ran with them.) Coaches meanwhile would be expected to prefer bio males as they reliably make a leaderboard.

The advantage of boys as young As 14 vs female Olympians is documented here.

If boys are faster than elite female athletes, should males compete in female athletics?

See how the best high school boys stack up against the best female Olympians and World Record holders in Track & Field and Swimming.

boysvswomen.com

Those charts are very telling. High school boys literally mopped up female Olympians. There were a very few exceptions. Many times, the top female Olympians wouldn't have even qualified for the finals versus the boys, even when the female Olympians set a new world or Olympic record.