Siouxhawk":2pyc78ze said:
Uncle Si":2pyc78ze said:
Siouxhawk":2pyc78ze said:
The players we had in for the topic of discussion easily could have made that work if executed properly, which is the tonic of every successful play. In fact, the personnel group was likely the same that had been in there practicing that particular package for 2 weeks.
If Ricardo gets to that spot a split second quicker, it's a touchdown. It's as simple as that.
Doesn't matter... it wasn't our strongest play call or using our best players to their strengths. It was a bad call and cost the team a Super Bowl. There really is no debate here.
You can breakdown why the play didn't work, but the fact is it asked role players to do important things in the biggest moment of the biggest game, and our QB to do something that's not his biggest attribute.
Bad. call.
And it's easy with 20/20 hindsight to say it wouldn't work and cost us 49, but Marshawn could have fumbled as well and you'd have the same end result and second guessing.
And as I said, the players in on that play were likely the ones practicing it for 2 weeks or longer leading up to the game. So all the coaches were in on it and knew what was coming. Only a brief hesitation by Ricardo off his break and a fantastic play by Butler in his coming-out party prevented a touchdown.
This speculation is based on what? We saw a receiver 5th on the depth chart do something a player 5th on the depth chart would do to justify that place on the depth chart in one of the most pivotal plays of the game. Yes, there were other plays that could have sealed the deal - those plays warrant introspection in themselves and detailing what went wrong and room for improvement. They are not excuses for an instance of the OC being seemingly agnostic towards the relative talents between his WR personnel.
The Seahawks coaching staff aren't infallible, they make mistakes like everyone else. They happened to make a gaffe in this case. By not taking ownership of that gaffe and assigning blame to the 5th WR who made hay on special teams, they stunted a huge learning opportunity and they continue to make little gaffes like this along the way in this vein. Like not directly addressing RW to Kearse despite it being a net negative all year long.
In some ways, I don't care if that the play itself failed, nothing to be done but learn from it. I don't feel they learned from it. And as long as you put everything on execution without any reference to the coaching staff putting players in the best position to execute to their ability, you'll just continue down this path of vacuous excuses for why Seahawks players can't get it done. It's a team game, start acting like coaches are part of the team.