Seymour
Active member
- Joined
- Nov 16, 2015
- Messages
- 7,459
- Reaction score
- 22
oldhawkfan":26bwvtdl said:Why are people mentioning Kearse as overrated? Is this subjective list of over/underrated predicated by fan opinion or coach opinion? If this is a fan based opinion, then there is no way in he'll that Kearse is overrated. I would be willing to bet serious money that at least 75% of the fan base dislikes him and wants an upgrade. That does not constitute overrated.
If this is a coach based rating system then I would argue that Kearse is probably neither. He is exactly what they see him as...servicable.
My own opinion on who I believe is overrated and underrated:
Overrated: Blair Walsh...im nervous about the kicking game and feel that little was done to replace Haushka.
Underrated: KJ Wright...he is the undersung member of the defense. Sure, he gets his accolades on occasion, but not like the bigger names.
This could turn out to be a big one. I could not overrate him yet without seeing if he still has the yips, but he may well turn out to be exactly that.
Hopefully we don't have to send out Ace to bring him in. :twisted: