Know what they should do

[Lithium]

Have a CO-ROOKIE OF THE YEAR for all 3 of the qb's. They're all damn good in their own way, they've done it for MVP so why not.

 

[JKent82]

I thought about this morning too! It kinda sorta makes sense honestly. I imagine RGIII wins it, but all three have done a lot a good.

 

[Sac]

Great minds. I was about to post this same thing.

 

[Erebus]

It could happen. All that has to happen is to split the vote evenly.

 

[two dog]

Never happen. Media attention trumps play on the field. Though to be fair, RG III's play
on the field has been impressive as well, Luck's less so.

 

[drdiags]

There can only be one (j/k, Manning and McNair shared MVP one season if I remember correctly).

 

[sc85sis]

We were talking about this at work today too. I'd be totally fine with it.

 

[onanygivensunday]

I watched NFL.com this afternoon and they had the results of a public poll on the offensive rookie of the year.

Russell Wilson won by an overwhelming margin of, if I recall correctly, almost 60% to about 30% for Andrew luck and about 15% for RGIII.

 

[BobcatHawk]

I'd be ok with it except that I don't really think Luck is as deserving as the other two. His yards are impressive, but to say that he raised a team from 2-14 to 11-4 is a farce. I'm still of the belief that the Colts tanked it on purpose last season and still had the talent on the roster to be competitive and that Luck should have done better given the talent and experience around him. JMHO

 

[bmorepunk]

Luck has been the QB for 7 game winning drives in 4Q/OT this year. That is the record since the merger. I know he's thrown a lot of INTs but let's not act like he hasn't done anything impressive.

 

[Twisted]

I for one would like to see the Seahawks not have any one particular player sensationalized to maintain the all for one one for all magic thats infected that team, all Seahawk rookies are playing well they just have different roles..

haha, I like that Rogers struggled hard to finally have a big game Sunday only to have it trumped by Seattle's disciplinary actions at the Woodshed, sum bottoms got spanked last night and Mr. Rogers had to be sitting there watching and thinking WTF? whats a guy gotta do to get top billing around here, I want my attention!!! hmmbooo? lol

I also like that Russel and company are not attention ho's but are ready to stand up and be counted when opponents get in their "intimidation mode" I already liked Marshawn as a player but when that niner got in his face trying to lay down the rules Marshawns pit bull reared and Lynch was like "huh, you? yea sure OK, hold on a sec, let me run this into the end zone first and I'll get back to ya" lol

dood had that look on his face like the girl that finally gets the nerve to come over and ask you to dance and you say, NO! it was priceless, NFL body language is funny at times "hey Forest I got this idea, see me an you we can get a shrimpin boat"

I think the niners inability to intimidate even the smallest of Seahawks players was prolly a lot more frustrating than the lockdown itself where even their kicker was getting shut down, ABSOLUTELY SPECTACULAR Red!!!! I think that play kicked off the frown festival?

gotta say it, that was the finest Seahawk game I can remember ever watching...

 

[HawKnPeppa]

Luck has been the QB for 7 game winning drives in 4Q/OT this year. That is the record since the merger. I know he's thrown a lot of INTs but let's not act like he hasn't done anything impressive.

But those pale in comparsion to his Int's, despite the fact that he usually has all day to throw. The evidence is overwhelming that the Colts intentionally tanked their season last year to get him. No way did their talent match that record. I could only imagine the numbers that RW and RGIII whould put up if they had Luck's pass catchers and played in that same system. Their passing yards would easily be 'Luckesche' with nowhere near the Int's he throws. Luck did NOT turn that team around...the team just started playing when they got their draft pick.

Don't get me wrong, Luch is having a 'good' season for rookie, but his performance at this point in his career is nowhere near what the other 2 rooks are doing.