What can I say? When a UDFA turns into a solid starter, it’s like finding a $100 bill in the street.
OK, but relevant examples here would be Jordan Babineaux, Doug Baldwin, Mike Bennett (sort of), George Fant, Poona Ford, Jermaine Kearse, Jon Kitna, Joe Nash, Thomas Rawls, DeShawn Shead, and Mack Strong.
Before anyone says that injuries stopped Rawls from being effective after that one season, I'll justify my inclusion of Rawls by pointing out that he produced about the same amount of on-the-field value in his first season as Sanborn has produced so far in two seasons, so while it's likely Sanborn will come out way ahead of Rawls in the end, so far they've been comparable (and Rawls more spectacular in his good moments). The rest of the Seahawks UDFAs I listed here are still way ahead of Sanborn. Yes, even Shead.
Way ahead. And I'd bet lunch that Sanborn won't get even close to catching Baldwin, Bennett, Kitna, or Nash in career value. It's not even a sure thing that Sanborn will catch Babineaux, Fant, Ford, or Kearse. Heck, he's still got quite a way to go to catch even Strong.
Plus I'm not sure what to do with guys like Krieg, Rufus Porter, Eugene Robinson, and Zorn. I included Nash, but including these guys kinda feels like cheating because the NFL was very different back in the '70s and '80s. But if we don't exclude these guys, that's four more
SEAHAWKS UDFAs I'd feel comfortable betting Sanborn won't even get close to catching in career value.
So when you're on a
SEAHAWKS fan site and you want to make a point about finding treasure among undrafted players, there are lots of examples more relevant to the
SEAHAWKS who have produced
a lot more than uh... (checks notes for the Nth time while writing this comment to try to remember this guy's name because it's slipped my mind yet again) Jack Sanborn, a guy who's started fewer than half his team's games in his first two seasons combined (16 of 34).
Don't get me wrong. Sanborn has been reasonably good so far, and what he's produced is already good value for an undrafted player. It's just that you were talking about him as if he were either a
SEAHAWKS player or a first-team All-Pro or something, and he's neither. I'm saying there are examples that are much better both in terms of being
SEAHAWKS players
and in terms of having produced much more on the field than Sanborn.
This reminds me of the very beginning of
South Park, when the boys see and meet Santa, Jesus, and Brian Boitano and then marvel at having actually met
the Brian Boitano. You're talking to fans of a team that has seen a bunch of its UDFAs have long and productive NFL careers, and you're getting all excited about a decent-so-far now-starting second-year linebacker. Sanborn as an example of finding a gem among UDFAs might fly on a Bears site, but around here there are much better examples to use.