Just for fun... my modified version of it came out as follows. I collapsed out the numerical scores, though I redid a lot of them. I don't claim any special expertise at the individual scores, but I didn't like some of his.
I also changed the performance/impact to only reflect the 2012 season... "what have you done for me lately"
Some of the most egregious, glaring issues in Hawkblogger's formula involved Lynch & Mebane.
Some of the issues with my modified one involve Rice and Clemons... but I think those are more factoring in injury concerns.
And it seems like Baldwin should be higher, and McCoy a little lower. Baldwin had a below-expectations season, while McCoy had an unexpectedly good season. That reflects the emphasis on 2012 performance. Also possibly Moffit should be higher. He was injured and/or beaten out by Sweezy a good chunk of the season.
The other thing that jumps out is the weakness of the DL position group going forward, plus the need for more talent in the OL.
So we'll see how those ratings stack up with what Pete & John DO as we move through the offseason.
RANK NAME POS. SCORE
1 Wilson, Russell QB 9.83
2 Sherman, Richard CB 9.50
3 Thomas, Earl FS 9.33
4 Wagner, Bobby LB 8.75
5 Lynch, Marshawn RB 8.67
6 Unger, Max C 8.42
7 Mebane, Brandon DT 8.33
8 Okung, Russell T 8.17
9 Wright, K.J. LB 8.17
10 Chancellor, Kam SS 8.00
11 Miller, Zach TE 8.00
12 Tate, Golden WR 8.00
13 Turbin, Robert RB 7.50
14 Irvin, Bruce DE 7.33
15 Sweezy, J.R. G 7.33
16 Browner, Brandon CB 7.33
17 Robinson, Michael FB 7.33
18 Giacomini, Breno T 7.17
19 Rice, Sidney WR 7.17
20 McCoy, Anthony TE 7.00
21 Lane, Jeremy CB 7.00
22 Baldwin, Doug WR 7.00
23 Ryan, Jon P 7.00
24 Bryant, Red DE 7.00
25 Clemons, Chris DE 6.83
26 Gresham, Clint LS 6.83
27 Scruggs, Greg DE 6.67
28 McQuistan, Paul T 6.67
29 Flynn, Matt QB 6.67
30 Branch, Alan DT 6.67
31 Smith, Malcolm LB 6.50
32 Johnson, Jeron SS 6.33
33 Kearse, Jermaine WR 6.33
34 Carpenter, James G 6.17
35 Howard, Jaye DT 6.00
36 Hauschka, Steven K 6.00
37 McDonald, Clinton DT 6.00
38 Jeanpierre, Lemuel G/C 6.00
39 Guy, Winston SS 6.00
40 Maragos, Chris CB 6.00
41 Washington, Leon RB 6.00
42 Moffitt, John G 5.83
43 Omiyale, Frank T/G 5.83
44 Thurmond, Walter CB 5.67
45 Jones, Jason DT 5.67
46 Morgan, Mike LB 5.50
47 Johnson, Rishaw G 5.50
48 Bradford, Allen LB 5.50
49 McGrath, Sean TE 5.50
50 Shead, DeShawn DB 5.50
51 Farwell, Heath LB 5.50
52 Maxwell, Byron CB 5.33
53 Person, Mike T 5.17
54 Hill, Leroy OLB 5.00
55 Butler, Deon WR 5.00
56 Trufant, Marcus CB 4.83
57 Obomanu, Ben WR 4.33