Not that I give a toot about McShay but if I read it right he had Barkley out of the first completely. I always thought he was the second coming of Clausen.
If you're talking about height, hair colour and the fact both grew up in California... they're pretty similar.
Apart from that... nothing alike at all.
McShay had Barkley as the #1 player on his board coming into the year. Up and down like a yo-yo.
Barkley's performance or McShay's analysis? Both shoes fit.
Shcrager at Fox now has three QB's in the first. None named Barkley. Now, even I think that's going to far.