Reading through this thread.... :34853_doh:
All I can say is the NFL and it's crazy constantly changing rules about a catch, and vague interpretations, and various conflicting opinions on what something is, like a "football move", has rubbed off on all of you!
They have you hook line and sinker if you are buying that wasn't a fumble.
Using the old fashion simple eye ball test, that was a fumble. He caught it, then he dropped it. Don't lawyer it all up and make it so confusing with a 100 variables when you don't have to. It was a catch, he ran with it, then he fumbled it.
It's not hard. :th2thumbs: