The only criticism I've seen this year is that the Offense (mostly due to Geno) stalls too often for too long a period of time (entire 2nd half Rams, most 1st half Detroit, 2nd half Giants), and this is valid.
We all know the ability is there, and the performance has been adequate, but a little more consistency and elevation is going to be needed when we face better teams. Starting with the Bengals.
Once the O-line gets healthy we’ll see an improved performance.
2nd half Rams- Both starting tackles injured in the opening 2:30 minutes
Most of first half Detroit- missing both starting tackles to injury and one of the guards got injured that game
2nd half Giants- both starting tackles missing to injury, starting LG injured, 2nd string RG injured, had to move the C to G and play a rookie C, 2nd string LT, RT, and 3rd string G.
There’s a consistent theme in those performances, but like you said the ability is there. Being healthy is the key.