I think a healthy Revis in 2011 really is better than Sherman. He might not rack up the stat page, but he was well ahead of Sherman in passer rating against. IIRC, advanced stats loved Revis more as well. That said, post Revis-ACL, I think Sherman's got a great argument. I do wish that both Revis and Sherman would curb the egos though. I guess that's hard to do when you are the best in the world at what you do, though.