Lynch vs. Alexander

The Essential Online Seahawks Fan Forum Community. There simply is NO substitute. RATING: PG-13

Better Running Back

Shaun Alexnader
49
24%
Marsahwn Lynch
153
76%
 
Total votes : 202

Re: Lynch vs. Alexander
Fri Dec 14, 2012 10:06 pm
  • In their prime - Shaun
    perfectly healthy - 'Shawn

    Lynch plays with back issues.
    "We walked our (pedestrian) ass to the Super Bowl"
    Angry Doug
    "We got grit. That's it."
    Earl Thomas.
    "Check your PMs"
    Pithy Radish.
    User avatar
    Rocket
    NET Veteran
     
    Posts: 1330
    Joined: Sat Jun 30, 2012 11:12 pm
    Location: The Rain Forest


Re: Lynch vs. Alexander
Sat Dec 15, 2012 12:12 am
  • Rocket wrote:In their prime - Shaun
    perfectly healthy - 'Shawn

    Lynch plays with back issues.

    Lynch plays old school smash-ur-ass Football, hard for me not to love them both for totally different styles, as both have served this team with real distinction. :th2thumbs:
    scutterhawk
    NET Veteran
     
    Posts: 3633
    Joined: Sun Apr 11, 2010 8:48 pm


Re: Lynch vs. Alexander
Sat Dec 15, 2012 12:29 am
  • I am not voting on this, SA was a beast in his prime Lynch is a beast now. Too tough a choice.
    Image
    "Tracy Porter lost his manhood when Marshawn stiff armed him" some dude on youtube.
    User avatar
    suppaball
    *BRONZE SUPPORTER*
    *BRONZE SUPPORTER*
     
    Posts: 2841
    Joined: Thu Apr 30, 2009 8:17 pm
    Location: Oroville CA.


Re: Lynch vs. Alexander
Sat Dec 15, 2012 2:05 am
  • I really appreciate both of them,but for the life of me I don't understand how most people here are taking Lynch EASILY??I guess fans typically go with he current guy,but I have not forgot a former MVP that ran for over 1800 yards and 27 TD's in a single season,most likely the greatest season a Hawk has ever had and he was far from a one hit wonder.We are fortunate to have had both of em!!
    User avatar
    Canhawks
    NET Rookie
     
    Posts: 135
    Joined: Sat May 02, 2009 6:12 am


Re: Lynch vs. Alexander
Sat Dec 15, 2012 2:20 am
  • Can't call it.
    Image Image Tanzania¹² Image "ALERT THE LEGION!!!"
    User avatar
    Zebulon Dak
    * The Producer *
    * The Producer *
     
    Posts: 14712
    Joined: Sun Mar 04, 2007 2:57 pm
    Location: King In The North


Re: Lynch vs. Alexander
Sat Dec 15, 2012 3:40 am
  • I can't believe this is even a conversation... Lynch is the best RB in Seahawks history, unfortunatly he plays behind a suspect line. The man doesn't quit and he doesn't shy away from contact. Lets be honest... SA did a lot of that unless he was near the goal line. SA was a product of the O Line, The Beastmode is productive despite his line. If anyone thinks that Lynch wouldn't have got more yards than SA with that rediculous line, they you really do need to put down the reefer... When Lynch goes untouched, yes he can be caught, but he is fast enough and tuff enough to have challenged or beat the all-time reg season rushing record behind the 05 Hawks line. One thing I am sure of: he would have had more class than SA had in 04... pouting on the sidelines...
    Position Before Submission
    The only thing worse than a miss is a S L O W miss
    User avatar
    The Grouch
    NET Practice Squad
     
    Posts: 73
    Joined: Sat Dec 01, 2012 3:45 am
    Location: BFEastern WA


Re: Lynch vs. Alexander
Sat Dec 15, 2012 3:59 am
  • Exhibit A:
    SA, 2005 reg season: 370 carries, 1880 yds, 5.1 ypa
    ML, 2012 reg season: 261 carries, 1266 yds, 4.9 ypa

    If Lynch gets 109 carries and holds anything close to his 4.9 ypa over the last three games he will be at or beyond 1700 yds on the season. This is less than SA's 1880 on the same number of carries, but with a significant downgrade in the OL department. Lynch IS the Seahawks running game. He gets his yards despite a suspect line. SA got his yards because of his line.
    Position Before Submission
    The only thing worse than a miss is a S L O W miss
    User avatar
    The Grouch
    NET Practice Squad
     
    Posts: 73
    Joined: Sat Dec 01, 2012 3:45 am
    Location: BFEastern WA


Re: Lynch vs. Alexander
Sat Dec 15, 2012 5:28 am
  • kearly wrote:
    Scottemojo wrote:I am very curious to know if this ranking accounts for all the yards Lynch gets after contact. If it doesn't, then it really doesn't make a statement about the line.


    You say yards after contact, I say vision. That said, I do think two things on this topic:

    #1: Lynch probably helps his FO line stats more than Alexander did because of his superior consistency.

    #2: The difference between the 2012 and 2005 lines is FAR smaller than the perception gap makes it out to be.

    I SO disagree. Beyond the obvious differences, like the use of zone blocking concepts, the answer to this comparison is simply 2 hall of famers.

    Last year, Lynch grew into a ZBS runner and then excelled while this line truly sucked and was chronically injured. What do you think Alexander would have done, even at his best, behind that line?
    Flip that. Put last year's Lynch behind the 05 line. Would he have been off of Alexander's pace? Those two scenarios say as much about the lines as the runners.

    I don't know the recent numbers, but as of the Vikings game, 40 percent of Lynch's yards were after contact. I doubt strongly that even in Alexander's MVP year he had 15 percent of his yards after contact.
    SEAHAWKS.NET. We All We Got, We All We Need
    User avatar
    Scottemojo
    *Scott of Smacksville*
    *Scott of Smacksville*
     
    Posts: 11227
    Joined: Thu Apr 30, 2009 9:14 am


Re: Lynch vs. Alexander
Sat Dec 15, 2012 8:24 am
  • This is a classic example of trying to compare "then & now". Its really not possible.

    If I could pick one back to have for the Seahawks in his prime it would be OJ. Wouldn't most of us? OJ was the hard running type like Lynch who hit the pile, hit the pile, hit the pile, and one time came out on the other side of the pile and ran away from everyone for 40-50 yards. And remember he broke Jim Brown's single season record in the same number of games per year 14, not the 16 Dickerson had to barely edge that record. And he is the only one to break Brown's record of 7 consecutive games of over 100 yards rushing.

    And there are others. If this O line could run decent sweeps I'd want Paul Hornung the best sweep runner ever, followed closely by Gayle Sayers. For straight speed runners no one compares to Sayers.

    But we can't have those people. As has been said, Alexander was the league MVP that year so for that year at least you nay sayers have to admit to his value. (but probably won't)

    Lynch is great for us now. His running style worrys me greatly as I go back to the 60s and can tell you that most backs that love contact like him have pretty short careers. I would love to have a really good O line for him to run behind so he won't have to take so much contact.

    So why do we have to like either one "best". I loved Shaun when he was in his prime, I love Lynch now. Why isn't that enough?

    :141847_bnono:
    Image
    On to week two. Week one was not a fluke!
    User avatar
    The Radish
    * NET Radish *
     
    Posts: 18655
    Joined: Tue Feb 27, 2007 8:18 pm
    Location: Spokane, Wa.


Re: Lynch vs. Alexander
Sat Dec 15, 2012 11:03 am
  • hawks4thewin wrote:I would take LEON over SHAUN i think in 2005 becuase he is faster than shuan and goes down just as easy.


    I think people toss this kind of thing out there way too willy nilly most of the time, but in this instance I really, really mean it.
    This is the most unbelievably moronic post I have ever read on this site. Ever, and it's not even close.

    hawks4thewin wrote:... someone more intelegent should comment


    Clearly...
    Football Outsiders wrote:The Seahawks have a third-and-long defensive DVOA of -102.1%. Seriously, when Seattle knows you have to pass, you are completely terribly, violently screwed.
    User avatar
    Chapow
    NET Veteran
     
    Posts: 1306
    Joined: Mon Jan 11, 2010 4:38 pm


Re: Lynch vs. Alexander
Sat Dec 15, 2012 11:36 am
  • I don't know if anyone's posted this already or not (if so, I apologize). This week on 710 ESPN Brock Huard had Robbie Tobeck and Craig Terrell in for a mini-roundtable on the 2005 vs. the 2012 Hawks. It was awesome to get an all ex-Seahawks perspective. At one point, Brock threw out the whole Alexander vs. Lynch question as well. I'm not sure if it was Terrell or Tobeck, but the response was (basically), "Could you imagine the kind of numbers Lynch would have put up behind that Offensive Line?" Though they gave a real PC answer, there was a whole lot of Lynch love from those guys. Here is the link to the interview. Great stuff ...

    2005 vs. the 2012 Hawks Roundtable
    User avatar
    Hawkscanner
    * NET Sage *
     
    Posts: 980
    Joined: Mon Jan 17, 2011 7:28 am


Re: Lynch vs. Alexander
Sat Dec 15, 2012 12:20 pm
  • Image
    User avatar
    Jville
    * NET Alumni *
     
    Posts: 3622
    Joined: Sat Mar 03, 2007 8:49 pm


Re: Lynch vs. Alexander
Sat Dec 15, 2012 12:23 pm
  • Not sure if this has been posted yet, if so I apologize. Although both are great runners in their own right, I feel Shaun fed the "soft" tag this team had for so long. Let's just say I am no longer worried about being embarrassed by my team's running back curling up into the fetal position.

    Yards are ultimately the highest measure, but to have your running back run about as mean as anyone ever has feels better to me. I just prefer the beatdown mentality over finesse.
    WolfGrey
    NET Bench Warmer
     
    Posts: 11
    Joined: Sun Nov 11, 2012 2:43 pm
    Location: Seminole, FL


Re: Lynch vs. Alexander
Sat Dec 15, 2012 12:27 pm
  • WolfGrey wrote:Not sure if this has been posted yet, if so I apologize. Although both are great runners in their own right, I feel Shaun fed the "soft" tag this team had for so long. Let's just say I am no longer worried about being embarrassed by my team's running back curling up into the fetal position.

    Yards are ultimately the highest measure, but to have your running back run about as mean as anyone ever has feels better to me. I just prefer the beatdown mentality over finesse.

    Great first post, and I agree with it. The soft label in 2005 used to piss me off, but it was true.
    SEAHAWKS.NET. We All We Got, We All We Need
    User avatar
    Scottemojo
    *Scott of Smacksville*
    *Scott of Smacksville*
     
    Posts: 11227
    Joined: Thu Apr 30, 2009 9:14 am


Re: Lynch vs. Alexander
Sat Dec 15, 2012 1:28 pm
  • Image

    Image

    Match the Running Back to the Picture :)
    Image

    To Be P/C or Not P/C That is the Question..........Seahawks kick Ass !!!!
    Check your PM's, Thank you for everything Radish RIP My Friend. :les:
    Member of the 38 club.
    User avatar
    chris98251
    .NET Hijacker
     
    Posts: 11189
    Joined: Tue Feb 27, 2007 10:52 pm
    Location: Renton Wa.


Re: Lynch vs. Alexander
Sat Dec 15, 2012 1:41 pm
  • Lynch has been consistent the last few years REGARDLESS of a passing game. Lynch> SA and it's not even close.
    Image Image
    User avatar
    AF_Hawk
    NET Veteran
     
    Posts: 2128
    Joined: Thu Apr 30, 2009 6:18 pm
    Location: Marysville, WA


Re: Lynch vs. Alexander
Sat Dec 15, 2012 2:01 pm
  • I'm a huge Alexander fan still and love the guy for what he did for us those several great years, but c'mon people. BeastMode FTW!! He's a stud, best we've ever had. And he plays hurt all the time behind a makeshift OL, never complains, and the players love him. We've had 2 of the Top 10 RBs of the last decade, I'd argue...
    User avatar
    Bryan
    NET Bench Warmer
     
    Posts: 14
    Joined: Sun Oct 14, 2012 10:25 am


Re: Lynch vs. Alexander
Sat Dec 15, 2012 2:03 pm
  • Just watched video of every TD in Alexander's 28 TD season. I counted 8 of those that I don't think Marshawn would have scored on. Watching the video, or any SA videos, really highlight the incredible 5-10 yard burst that he had, and then the long speed. I love to watch Marshawn play, but that burst that Shaun had is up there with the best to have every played the game.

    Lynch has enough years left where he could pass SA in time, but for me, he's not there yet.
    drrew
    NET Starter
     
    Posts: 490
    Joined: Tue Mar 02, 2010 8:50 am


Re: Lynch vs. Alexander
Sat Dec 15, 2012 2:50 pm
  • Jville wrote:Image


    That's my man.
    User avatar
    bmorepunk
    NET Veteran
     
    Posts: 841
    Joined: Sun Jan 02, 2011 12:56 pm


Re: Lynch vs. Alexander
Sat Dec 15, 2012 3:22 pm
  • Jville wrote:Image


    THIS :th2thumbs:

    Still my all-time greatest RB in Seattle !!

    ...WE ARE...
    "If You're Good At Making Excuses, You'll Never Be Great At Anything Else." ~ Richard Sherman

    GO HAWKS !!
    User avatar
    glowingeyedseahawk
    * PA's # 1 Seahawks Fan *
     
    Posts: 545
    Joined: Sat Mar 03, 2007 8:42 pm
    Location: Sinking Spring, PA


Re: Lynch vs. Alexander
Sat Dec 15, 2012 3:52 pm
  • I was looking for some vids of Curt, found one for his second season back from injury but hard to dig them up, was looking for his rookie year which if you seen the KC game was jaw dropping.

    Trouble I had was Kurt Warner dominated the search.
    Image

    To Be P/C or Not P/C That is the Question..........Seahawks kick Ass !!!!
    Check your PM's, Thank you for everything Radish RIP My Friend. :les:
    Member of the 38 club.
    User avatar
    chris98251
    .NET Hijacker
     
    Posts: 11189
    Joined: Tue Feb 27, 2007 10:52 pm
    Location: Renton Wa.


Re: Lynch vs. Alexander
Sat Dec 15, 2012 4:13 pm
  • Depends on the line.

    With a great oline I take Alexander - he had such great vision,instincts and moves and significantly better top end speed than Marshawn.

    With a great oline, obviously Lynch would be great but not-Alexander great.

    Where Lynch gets the adavantage is if the the oline isn't special. Marshawn can run the ball not matter what the blocking is like becasue he is so hard to tackle and plays with so much passion.

    If I have to draft one not knowing what my line is like I am taking Lynch because he is instant running game and brings a toughness that SA never did. I think both guys are ideally suited to the versions of the Seahawks teams they play on. Marshawn would never look as bas as SA did when the line collapsed though.

    Give me Marshawn, I much prefer the identity that his style provides of Alexander's - and I am big fan of SA but his running was condusive to looking great behind a great oline.

    Lynch is all heart, SA was the natural.
    kobebryant
    NET Veteran
     
    Posts: 1216
    Joined: Sat May 23, 2009 1:45 pm


Re: Lynch vs. Alexander
Sat Dec 15, 2012 4:20 pm
  • No one can ever downplay Alexander's accomplishments and he was absolutely great for us, but go to YouTube and watch a video of all 28 of his TDs in 05. Soooo many from about 3 yards out and even his longer ones were pretty much untouched.
    SeaToTheHawks
    NET Rookie
     
    Posts: 109
    Joined: Tue Oct 30, 2012 10:15 pm


Re: Lynch vs. Alexander
Sat Dec 15, 2012 7:11 pm
  • It's my understanding that Lynch has never been behind an offensive line like our 2005 line, so to say he wouldn't do as well is not accurate IMO. And Lynch is just now getting a passing game to supplement the run which SA had the majority of his career.
    Image Image
    User avatar
    AF_Hawk
    NET Veteran
     
    Posts: 2128
    Joined: Thu Apr 30, 2009 6:18 pm
    Location: Marysville, WA


Re: Lynch vs. Alexander
Sat Dec 15, 2012 9:14 pm
  • Did Alexander have the 2005 Offensive Line in 2002-2004...
    "Go for Broke" - 442nd Japanese-American Battalion

    Shaun Alexander #37 for the HoF - 119 Games 2176 Att 9429 Yards 4.3 YPC 100 TDs (112 TDs total) 2005 MVP

    "YOU POST...TO WIN...thethread." JesterHawk
    User avatar
    sammyc521
    *GOLD SUPPORTER*
    *GOLD SUPPORTER*
     
    Posts: 4212
    Joined: Sat Mar 03, 2007 2:42 pm
    Location: Pacific Ocean


Re: Lynch vs. Alexander
Sat Dec 15, 2012 9:46 pm
  • sammyc521 wrote:Did Alexander have the 2005 Offensive Line in 2002-2004...


    Actually...yes he did.
    "Pete Carroll brings in great elves...and they make the best presents."
    User avatar
    SacHawk2.0
    .NOT a Moderator
     
    Posts: 10367
    Joined: Thu Apr 30, 2009 4:51 pm
    Location: With a white girl


Re: Lynch vs. Alexander
Sun Dec 16, 2012 2:13 pm
  • Is there now an option for Wilson? This dude's got a NOSE for the ENDZONE!

    Hustle Wilson!
    "Your Seattle Seahawks, 2013-14 World Champions"
    Adopt A Rookie 2014-15 - Kevin Pierre-Louis
    Adopt-A-Red-Shirt 2014-15 Christine Micheal
    Previously known as megamanflx1
    User avatar
    Seahawkscrazy
    NET Veteran
     
    Posts: 973
    Joined: Sat Mar 03, 2007 12:59 pm
    Location: Dallas, TX


Previous


It is currently Mon Oct 20, 2014 5:13 pm

Please REGISTER to become a member

Return to [ THE OFFICIAL NET NATION FAN FORUM ]




Information