JSeahawks wrote:ClumsyLurk wrote:ASJ is having a down year, no.?
Square peg in a round hole in this offense.
SeatownJay wrote:Onside kick?
pehawk wrote:Why did the clock still run anyways?
JSeahawks wrote:Ball hit the grass. Sorry.
Spounge84 wrote:JSeahawks wrote:Ball hit the grass. Sorry.
Doesn't matter as long as Smith had control of it, which to me it appeared he did.
DavidSeven wrote:Not enough to overturn if those are the only angles. Not indisputable.
This isn't a conversation if ASJ makes that catch.
SeatownJay wrote:This team's going to be pissed off for next week's game against Oregon.
Tru2RedNGold25 wrote:Us as Niners fan have every right to rep Niners all day everyday when we have the hardware to back it up do can u guys say that???
Msfann wrote:It may have hit the ground but I didn't see enough evidence to overturn it. Even on a 60" plasma you could see ball but nothing to prove without a doubt that it touched.
And that's the problem they have to know for sure to overturn it and you can't say for 100% sure that it did touch. They got hosed.
If the ruling on the field originally was that it was dropped and then the replay came back saying it hit the ground that would have been fine. But the original call was a catch and there just wasn't enough proof to overrule the ruling on the field.