themunn wrote:Why not?
3rd all-time in receptions, 2nd in TDs with only Rice and TO ahead, despite the likes of Daunte Culpepper (who was a product of Moss and not vice versa), Kerry Collins and Alex Smith making the bulk of his passes (3 seasons of a HoF QB compared to the entire career that Rice had with Montana and then Young throwing the ball makes a difference).
I'd say it's neck and neck between the two
Randy past TO this season in TDs. You were correct in saying he is 2nd all time, but TO is not ahead.
You forgot Tom Brady as a QB throwing to him. In terms of Randy's 14 year career, Alex Smith barely had an impact.
Edit: But I agree with themunn. I think it's closer than most people admit.