Here is a conversation between Sando and Carroll about the new rule...

http://espn.go.com/blog/nfcwest/post/_/id/94838/pete-carroll-helmet-rule-good-for-game

If I understand this correctly, leading with the forehead area is legal, but leading with the top of the head is not. If this is the case, I don't see this being too impactful on the game.

NOT 5 times last year. 5 times in week 17 alone. So that would be roughly 85 calls in a single year.

Kickoffs have nothing to do with this thread. I never mentioned kickoffs.

And I did not say "change" the game. I was trying to find out the specific reason(s) why some people use the word "ruin" to describe what the crown rule is doing.

When I played in high school I was taught that no contact should be initiated with the crown of the helmet. So if this rule is "ruining" the game because it eliminates the battering effect of the crown of the helmet, then I guess my HS coaches were ruining football right from the get-go for me.

The game has seen many, many changes. This rule, by itself, is so minor as compared to so many other changes in the game's history (plastic helmets, facemasks, goal posts moved off the field, etc.). It's going to be in the application of it, i.e., how often it is called and how accurately it is called, that will determine how much it changes – or even ruins – the game.

_________________

How many little things cost us the division and a bye week last season? I don't think I'll soon get over that delay of game in the 49ers-Rams game. I wouldn't make the argument above. Little things can make a huge difference in hyper competitive situations.

As far as the rule, it would be a better rule if it was reviewable. Human error is what worries me, and I think the argument that this might increase injuries has some traction.

It didn't result in a penalty, but remember all the hand wringing over the Golden Tate block in the Dallas game last year? If nothing else, I'd like to tamper down that mindless debate, not exacerbate it. This isn't a good direction for the league to head in, IMO.

I'd support a system where plays are reviewed after games and fines/suspensions might be a consideration (1 game suspensions for flagrant/multiple offenders). That way you are incentivising safe play without inviting blown calls.

_________________

"I believe there’s merit to the idea that once something in life becomes conventional, it’s no longer the safest path to success." -Matt Waldman
"If everyone's thinking alike, no one's thinking." -Bill Walsh

I already posted earlier, but this league is starting to become a joke to me. If you can get past the 120-180min of commercials and stoppages and actually get to the 60mins of game time then you are a pro in your own right. It's just getting to point of unwatchable and all the pussy rules and over advertising is starting to make me sick. Unreal.

This.

Much ado about nothing, imo. The people most upset probable have no idea about this rule and think "physical play" isn't allowed anymore.

_________________
Team Hansen

None of this explains to me why you shouldn't care about their health. Nobody deserves to be paralyzed or become demented for your amusement. I worry about the subjectivity of this rule, and I'm not convinced it's going to work in practice, but as a philosophy I'm glad the league is trying to prolong players' careers and lives.

Feel free to stop watching

_________________

Steve Mariucci comments

http://www.nfl.com/videos/nfl-network-total-access/0ap2000000152448/Steve-Mariucci-addresses-new-helmet-hit-rule

And Charles Woodson

http://www.nfl.com/videos/nfl-network-total-access/0ap2000000152158/Woodson-on-new-rules-free-agency?continuous=true

Edit: Mayock doesn't like it:

http://www.nfl.com/videos/nfl-network-total-access/0ap2000000152140/Mayock-on-new-rule-We-ve-crossed-a-line

_________________
Joe Vellano, DT, 6'1", 300lbs, 61 tkls 14 TFL, 6 sacks" http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Nc_yzeVi-eU, Mike Catapano 6'4" 271
QB Jordan Rodgers 6'1" 212# 2539 Yards, 60% completion 15td/5int

You know what's really stupid? "The NFL went back and looked at week 17 games say they only would have called the penalty 5 or 6 times." Uh...wtf? They were reviewing film, a referee has to call it in real-time and decide "intent."

Once this starts screwing teams over and deciding games, it will be changed, but it will be too late then.

This should be reviewable because the play by MikeRob would have been called a penalty and would have been wrong.

_________________
Joe Vellano, DT, 6'1", 300lbs, 61 tkls 14 TFL, 6 sacks" http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Nc_yzeVi-eU, Mike Catapano 6'4" 271
QB Jordan Rodgers 6'1" 212# 2539 Yards, 60% completion 15td/5int

As the hit shown in your avatar, Tate gets a fine from the League for leading with the SIDE of his helmet, and we don't have a thing to fuss over?, no Referee mistake there?
That was a bullshit call, going all the way to the top, and NOT being corrected, okay, I trust that the Refs won't make that same mistake again, and again, and again, and again.
Kam's hit on V.D. and again, and again,,,OH, that's right!, he didn't get fined for that, but the 15 yard +++ penalty was still upheld without a review to overturn because it was the Ref that made a MISTAKE ,and NOT Kam.

Like your avatar which was a clean hit it matters how its seen by the zebras in real time. Just like Kam's hit on #85, it was legal but drew 3 flags, tha means 3 refs blew that call on the same play! Instead of making more rules, they need to streamline the rules and simplify the rule book so there is less gray area. Good gawd how I hate Rog Goodell!

_________________
Hugh Millen = CBJ minus the cool beard

So the new rule is essentially taking spearing, which has been illegal for years on the defensive side of the ball, and extending that over to the offense?

_________________
I hate Tim Ruskell.

Yes. But only if its in the open field.

_________________

HOW UNREASONABLE!!!

Seriously, this rule change is miniscule.

6 pages of posts is 5.5 pages too many.

_________________
I hate Tim Ruskell.

Exactly. I guess everything is going so well for the Seahawks this offseason people need something to bitch about.

_________________

Mike Rob and Marshawn Lynch disgusted by the rule..

Rob said Marshawn even said "I dont wanna play anymore"

Live on Total access right now. Wow.

I dont think i've ever seen Marshawn lead with the crown of his helmet. I'd be surprised if he drew a single flag next season. In hte open field he usually just uses his stiff arm or runs thru arm tackles.

He did plant his facemask about 8 inches into Goldston's chest though.

_________________

Mike Rob said that he was taught his whole life to deliver the blow, and not to accept it, and looking at this new rule, in real time, is gonna be extremely tough for power backs to deliver the blow when the defender is getting low