therealjohncarlson wrote:Well since a team ranging from across a whole season wouldn't make sense for this question, my question assumed the two teams were using their Dec 24 teams,which I actually made clear in my OP.
I still have a hard time voting against the '05 team. The '05 team won 11 straight games in a row. No let downs except in game 4 where Slave-to-the-Businessman doinked a FG off the up-right.
The '12 team as exciting as they are not as consistent in my opinion. Are they more exciting? Questionable. Our '05 was an efficient killer with long-sustaining drives that would gas defenses and then our rapid defense would force turnovers.
Again, I feel that people are nothing thinking of Alexander, Hasselbeck, Darrel Jackson, Mack Strong, Walter Jones, Steve Hutchinson, Bryce Fisher, Grant Wistrom, Lofa Tatupu, Marcus Trufant, etc in their Prime.
Could this '12 evolve into a better team? Mos def... but after week 16, the '05 team just rattled off their 11th consecutive win. Even as electric as this '12 team is, they have not shown that ability.