I vote no for Russell Wilson for Rookie of the Year

I do however fully support him for NFL MVP. He took a really scattered and not very good team and turned them into an offensive juggernaut the likes of which I've never seen (over the last 3 weeks). The team will finish with double digit wins for the first time in the Carroll era, and he is playing some of the most composed and impressive football of anybody EVER. MVP MVP MVP MVP. He's like Ichiro, Ken Griffey Jr., Kenny Easley, and Gary Payton all wrapped up in a Seahawks uni.

Why can't he win both?

I just figured if I put the no about ROY that I'd get more responses.

I dont think he'll win it but i've been saying for the past few weeks that he should be in the discussion and in the top 5 for MVP.

If I had a vote i'd probably give it to Adrian Peterson.

jkitsune":2u879ebf said:

Why can't he win both?

Click to expand...

Hear Hear I am for both, best QB in the history of the Hawks. Yes I love you Hasselbeck but you were never RW

I fully agree. this kid is putting up MVP numbers.

Homer aside. No one is better then AP, J.J, Brady, Johnson and Manning this season. They are putting up crazy numbers. Wilson has no shot this season.

150 points in 3 games should give voters a reason to pause. Putting up 42 as a rookie on the best defense in the league should give them pause. Beating Brady and Rodgers in his rookie season should give them pause.

I agree. I think Manning, Brady, Rodgers, Peterson, Wilson, and Griffin all deserve nominations.

I think right now, I'd vote for Manning or Brady, but Wilson is worth every bit as much to his team as those guys are.